A common question we are asked in our retail store is to explain the difference between galvanised steel and painted steel, helping our customers decide which is the best option for their needs.
In this article we will compare these two, explain what each one is, then outlining the pros and cons for each of these.
What is galvanised steel?
Galvanised steel is simply steel that has been given a coating of zinc, which helps protect the steel from corrosion.
The actual galvanisation process involves:
- Cleaning the steel
- Creating a molten zinc solution that is heated to about 450 degrees
- Dipping the steel in this molten zinc solution
- This produces a chemical reaction that results in a substance called zinc carbonate
Upon dipping, the zinc will bond to the steel, hardening out of the solution. This coating protects the steel layer underneath from moisture and elements such as salts, preventing corrosion while also increasing the strength of the steel.
What is painted steel?
As the name suggests, painted steel is exactly that: a layer of paint is applied to steel, creating a protective layer from the elements.
The process of applying paint to steel involves:
- Cleaning the steel using a technique called sandblasting
- This also roughens up the surface, allowing the paint to bond better
- Spray the paint
What are the differences between galvanised and painted steel?
|Thickness is consistent across one piece of steel
|Coating thickness can vary across one piece of steel
|Durable coating, hard to scratch
|Less durable coating, easy to scratch
|Paint is a barrier protection only – scratches expose the steel underneath
|More expensive than using paint
|Cheaper than galvanising
|Due to the greater hardness of galvanisation, it is more corrosion resistant and requires less maintenance over time
|An enamel coat can be applied over the paint for extra strength and durability
|You can have any colour as long as it is silver
|Colour choices are infinite
|Naturally lasts for many years, around 50 years
|After 3-5 years the paint wears down, and at the 5-7 year mark a recoat of paint will be required
What does The Haggarty Group recommend?
As you can see in the table above, both have negatives and advantages.
If you are after a lower cost option with colour choices, paint coatings are quite effective. Having said this, there are several situations that will better suit galvanised steel, such as:
- Do you live near the coast? If yes, then we are sure you know that salty air is the enemy of steel. For this reason, galvanised steel is a much sturdier option.
- Are you using the steel as part of a livestock shelter? If yes, then be aware that waste from animals can be corrosive, and for such applications galvanised steel is a preferred option.
- Lastly, if you need to frequently wash the steel (for example if its part of your shed), of if it is regularly exposed to water, then galvanised steel will give you more longevity.
How can we help you?
At The Haggarty Group, we have the knowledge and experience to help you with any of your steel-related projects. Come in store for a chat, or give us a call today.